Home › Situations › a player wants to play
What to reply to an agent: “a player wants to play”?
An agent writes to you in Shadow Director: the situation, the three possible replies and what they change.
The situation
The three replies, and what they change
Reply A : « If he wants to leave, let him go. »
Tone : badly received. Reaction : « Very well, we'll study the offers. »
- Stress +1 (unfavourable)
Reply B : « He will get playing time, I promise. »
Tone : well received. Reaction : « I'll pass it on, he's counting on you. »
- Coach -2 (unfavourable)
Reply C : « He must first convince the coach. »
Tone : neutral. Reaction : « That's an answer. He won't like it. »
- No quantified effect
How does each reply compare?
In the game’s data, reply B (“He will get playing time, I promise.”) is the best received, at the cost of Coach -2.
When this message arrives
The game picks this message when a substitute with low morale (under 70) complains about playing time.
And then? The follow-up
Depending on your reply, the conversation goes on:
If you pick reply B
The other person comes back with : « What if we found a compromise: a few appearances in the cup? »
- Alright for the cup. (well received ; Coach -1)
- Nothing guaranteed. (neutral)
- He stays in the squad, full stop. (badly received ; Stress +1)
Our take
The real choice: reply B is the best received but costs you Coach -2, while C costs nothing and is neutral.
Why it matters
Agents defend their player and their own interests: your tone and your money decide how a transfer goes.