Home › Situations › The captain
What to reply to your coach: “The captain”?
Your coach writes to you in Shadow Director: the situation, the three possible replies and what they change.
The situation
The three replies, and what they change
Reply A : « Let’s keep the current captain. »
Tone : neutral. Reaction : « Very well, we carry on like this. »
- Coach -1 (unfavourable)
- Stress -1 (favourable)
Reply B : « Let the dressing room vote. »
Tone : well received. Reaction : « Original, the players will like it. »
- Coach +1 (favourable)
- Reputation +1 (favourable)
Reply C : « Good idea, pick him. »
Tone : well received. Reaction : « I will talk to the group about it. »
- Coach +2 (favourable)
How does each reply compare?
In the game’s data, reply B (“Let the dressing room vote.”) is the best received: it brings Coach +1, Reputation +1.
When this message arrives
The game picks this message at any point in the season.
And then? The follow-up
Depending on your reply, the conversation goes on:
If you pick reply A
The other person comes back with : « The captain change caused some reaction. Some see it as a sign of distrust. What do you tell them? »
- It is the coach’s choice. (neutral ; Coach +2)
- I don’t want to hear about it any more. (badly received ; Coach -1, Stress +1)
- It is a collective decision. (well received ; Coach +1)
Our take
Reply B is well received and costs nothing, and it brings Coach +1, Reputation +1: no trade-off here. Watch out for reply A: it brings Stress -1 but is judged neutral.
Why it matters
Your relationship with the coach influences the team’s strength and his choices: what you answer him matters more than it seems.